News

Imo: Supreme Court Hears Ihedioha’s Application, Delivers Judgment 3pm Today

supreme-court-jscs

The Supreme Court on Tuesday finally heard the application for review of the January 14 judgement, filed by the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and its candidate, Emeka Ihedioha, which sacked him as the governor of Imo State.

Mr. Ihedioha and the PDP told the apex court, which installed Senator Hope Uzodinma as the governor of Imo State, at today’s hearing that the judgement was obtained by fraud.

They therefore prayed the seven-man panel, headed by the Chief Justice of Nigeria, Tanko Muhammed, to set aside the judgment.

Chief Kanu Agabi, counsel to Mr. Ihedioha, said that fraud is evident in the judgment, as the appellant, Hope Uzodinma, claimed he was excluded from 388 polling units but tendered results from only 366 polling units.

He argued that the addition of votes from 388 polling units in favour of Senator Uzodinma exceeds the total number of accredited voters by 129,000 votes.

Agabi also asked why Uzodinma, who contended that the election was invalid and sought a rerun in the affected polling units, was declared the winner of the election he had condemned.

He said, “We are not here to challenge the supremacy of this court. We acknowledge the supremacy of this court. This court is supreme and your judgments are final.

“My lords, it as we go to God to change his mind that we have come to you to change your mind.

“It is better for those aggrieved to come to your lordships grumble than to grumble at home.”

Agabi continued, “At least 34 times, reference was made to 388 polling units where the respondents said their results were excluded.

“But they tendered results only in respect of 366, yet your lordships gave them credit for 388. That is giving them credit 22 polling units from nowhere.

“Contrary to all the precedents, the number of votes cast by their own computation exceeded the number of accredited voters in the election by over 129,000.

“They stigmatised the election as invalid. Being invalid how could it be the grounds upon which they are elected? If an election is invalid it should result in its nullification.

“From all our pleadings and what I have submitted, fraud is evident. If it is not fraud it is a fatal error.

“How does he do it. What magic is this? That is why it came under suspicion.

“He pleaded invalidity. He said elections should be conducted in 366. He said give me elections in 366 where his results were excluded.

“The import is that he gets a benefit for which he did not seek. He got benefits inconsistent with his pleadings.”

The learned distingisuhed the Imo case from that of Bayelsa.

“Our case is different from that of Bayelsa.

“In my upbringing when I was a child, my father would beat me to cry, he would also beat me to stop crying.

“We are crying and we have come before to you, do not do like my father did. Do not beat us like my father did.”

He therefore prayed the court to restore the verdict of the Court of Appeal, which had affirmed Ihedioha’s victory at the poll.

But Damien Dodo (SAN), lawyer to Senator Hope Uzodinma, countered, saying that the application to review or set aside the judgment of the court is an incompetent one lacking in merit.

He said the supreme court lacks the jurisdiction to sit on appeal over any judgment delivered by the court except where cases of typographical errors or slips are noticed in the said judgment are established and in this case, no such errors have been established.

The apex court will deliver judgment by 3pm today.

Leave a Reply